This is the best buttermilk panna cotta! It has a smooth, creamy texture with the perfect amount of gelatin to allow easy unmolding. This easy recipe has a vanilla flavor with a little tang from buttermilk tamed by a touch of brown sugar.
Place 6 molds or ramekins on a rimmed baking sheet. Spray lightly with nonstick cooking spray.
Bloom the gelatin: If using sheet gelatin, place individual sheets into ice water and allow to soften. This will take 5 minutes. Remove gelatin sheets and squeeze out excess water. Place in a dish to the side until ready to use, but don’t do this step more than 10 minutes in advance or the sheets will begin drying out. Rather, store them in the ice water.
If using powdered gelatin: In a small bowl whisk together the gelatin and cold water. Allow to sit undisturbed for 5 minutes.
In a small pot bring ½ cup heavy cream, milk, salt and sugars just to a boil, stirring frequently to dissolve the sugars.
Remove the pot with the boiling cream mixture from the heat, and add the bloomed gelatin. Stir to dissolve the gelatin.
In a separate bowl or blender, combine the remaining cold cream, buttermilk and vanilla. Pour the gelatin mixture into the cold ingredients and either briefly blend in blender or use a hand blender to incorporate. You can also use a whisk rather than a blender, but a blender will give the best final texture.
Divide between lightly sprayed molds. Cover with plastic wrap and chill completely. 2 hours is the minimum but sometimes they still will not unmold. I like to ride the line between using just enough and not enough gelatin. This produces a panna cotta with perfect mouth feel. It should melt in the mouth rather than feel like Jello. To that effect, I chill overnight always.
To unmold, place desired serving plate or bowl upside down over the mold. Shake to loosen the panna cotta from the mold and it should fall on the plate. In the Italian restaurant where I served this (and a bunch of other varieties), we briefly ran the outside of the mold under hot water (or dip in a bowl of hot water), over turn and shake it into your hand, then gently place on the plate or bowl for serving. I prefer the look of fluted metal molds but ramekins also work.
Macerated strawberries:
About an hour or so before serving, combine strawberries, sugar, zest and lemon juice in a bowl. Stir to distribute the sugar. Taste and adjust sweetness or lemon juice as needed.
Cover and refrigerate at least an hour. This can be done the day before but eventually the strawberries will soften and be less pretty. Still tasty but not cute.
Pile a few strawberries on top and allow some to fall to the side and add some of the strawberry juices to the plate.
Notes
Yield – 6 Servings Presentation – Serve with baked streusel, toasted or candied nuts or granola for a crunchy component and then the macerated strawberries or any other fresh fruit or berries. Flavor Tips – Be sure the buttermilk and additional cream are cold, so that the mixture cools quickly and the buttermilk doesn’t curdle. Storage – Store buttermilk panna cotta in the refrigerator for up to 3 days or frozen for 2 months. I do recommend storing them covered and unmolding immediately before serving. If frozen, allow 2 hours to thaw in the fridge after unmolding.