Hundreds of years ago colonists had already created and perfected an iconic Southern American dessert: The Sweet Potato Pie. They have transformed the humble sweet potato into a dessert that is absolutely sensational! I will never look at a sweet potato the same again. No longer will it be relegated to a Thanksgiving side-dish.
This is no ordinary sweet potato pie either. This is Mary Randolph’s Sweet Potato Pie and it is extraordinary. She masterfully combines brandy, lemon juice, lemon zest, vanilla extract and sweet potatoes into a pie that is positively bursting with flavor.
The zing of the lemon counterbalances the sweetness from the sweet potatoes, and the brandy adds additional depth of flavor. This pie would show up even the best pumpkin pies.
Mary Randolph first published her influential cookbook The Virginia Housewife in 1824, which is generally considered to be the first Southern cookbook. This recipe is nestled in there as Sweet Potato Pudding. Mary Randolph was still in the habit of calling all desserts, pie or otherwise, puddings in the British sense of the word.
Call it what you will, the flavors blew me away.
I actually found this recipe in The Southern Heritage Pies and Pastry Cookbook (1984 Edition), which is undeniably my current obsession. You’ll be seeing a lot more from this cookbook because it’s ridiculous. In short, Ridiculously Amazing.
Want. To. Make. Pie. Every. Night. Must. Resist.
I baked this pie in a cream cheese crust that will particularly bowl you over. The crust was a botched first attempt at the pastry for Apricot Kolaches. It turns out that if you don’t follow the instructions exactly, you subsequently end up with a mess (and possibly tears).
Never one to waste, I pulled together the dough with some ice water, wrapped it in plastic wrap and threw it in the freezer to deal with later. Well thank heavens I sometimes forget to follow instructions! It’s now one of my favorite piecrusts and it’s super easy because you don’t have to cut the butter into the flour. Nope, for this reason, you get to use a hand mixer! Heck yes!
Instead of using the cream cheese crust as given below, you can also use my other favorite piecrust recipe, which would be equally amazing!
Paired with Lemon Whipped Cream this pie will be a hit in the Summer, Winter or by all means a welcome addition to any Thanksgiving table.
P.S. – The secret to the bright orange color in this (and any) sweet potato pie is boiling the sweet potatoes instead of baking them.
This recipe masterfully combines brandy, lemon juice, lemon zest, vanilla extract and sweet potatoes into a pie that is positively bursting with flavor! It will change the way you look at sweet potatoes forever!
For the Cream Cheese Crust:
1 cup +2 tablespoons all-purpose flour
¼ teaspoon salt
4 oz cream cheese
1/2 cup unsalted butter, softened
ice water as needed
For the Sweet Potato Filling:
¼ cup butter, unsalted, softened
1 cup sugar
2 cups cooked, mashed sweet potatoes
3 eggs, room temperature
¼ cup brandy [I use E&J XO Extra Smooth Brandy]
2 teaspoons grated lemon zest (be careful not to get the bitter, white pith!)
Sift flour and salt together in a medium bowl and set aside.
Beat the cream cheese and butter together with a stand mixer or a hand mixer until completely incorporated and creamy (3-5 minutes).
Reduce the speed of the mixer and add in the flour. Mix until the dough comes together. If the dough is not cohesive and will not stay in a ball, sprinkle ice water a teaspoon at a time over the dough and mix with a fork until it comes together in a ball.
Flatten into a circle, wrap in plastic wrap and refrigerate until hard, at least 4 hours. Overnight refrigeration is recommended.
Roll out your pastry to 1/8th inch thick and line a pie dish, trim the edges, roll them under and crimp decoratively. Cover loosely and place in the refrigerator until ready to fill.
To Prepare the Filling:
Preheat oven to 400°
Place brandy in a small pan and heat until warm. Do not boil. Keep warm.
Cream butter in a mixing bowl with a hand mixer: gradually add sugar, beating well after each addition. Add potatoes; beat on medium speed until well blended.
Add eggs, one at a time; beating after each addition.
Add the brandy, lemon zest, lemon juice, vanilla and nutmeg to the sweet potato mixture; stir until well blended.
Pour mixture into pastry shell.
Bake at 400° for 15 minutes. Lower the temperature to 350° and continue baking until a knife inserted into the center comes out clean, about 25 more minutes.
For the photos, I halved the filling recipe to make two mini pies, so that is always an option!
Cooking and Mashing Sweet Potatoes: Peel the sweet potatoes (you will need 2-3 for this recipe). Cut them into golf ball sized chunks and place in a medium saucepan. Pour in cold water just to cover then bring to a boil over medium high heat. Boil until a fork can be inserted easily into the center of the largest chunk. Drain. You have several options at this point: you can use a ricer, which is what I did; you can throw them in a food processor, which is probably what I should have done; or you can mash them by hand, which is so not recommended! Let them cool to room temperature prior to preparing the filling.
A note on Brandy – I use E&J XO Extra Smooth Brandy; a more expensive, barrel aged brandy with almost floral notes. If you use a different brandy or one with a higher alcohol content (greater than 80 proof), you might want to reduce the brandy by half and taste as you go. You want to have a subtle brandy flavor but it shouldn’t overwhelm the dish.